Saturday, May 10, 2008
Propping Up the 'Ganda
The article focuses on Richard Weikart, author of From Darwin to Hitler: Evolutionary Ethics, Eugenics, and Racism in Germany. According to the article, Weikart makes the following claims (though without connecting them):
- Evolutionary ethics was an important factor in the shift in the late 19th and early 20th century away from a Judeo-Christian sanctity-of-life ethic;
- "Darwinists," promoted infanticide, eugenics, euthanasia and the elimination of aboriginal peoples because they believed that natural selection was a "good" process and that humanitarian institutions (hospitals, religions) set aside the benefits of natural selection and should be eliminated;
- Such thoughts "influenced" Hitler and the Nazi party, "feeding into" Hitler's and the Nazis' ideology of promoting a racial struggle for existence that resulted in the so-called extermination of inferior human races; and
- Expelled does a really good job of raising such issues but cannot explore Darwinism and Nazism to any real depth sufficient to truly explain the "connection" -- people who are interested can explore it further "on their own," (oh, say, by reading Weikart's book).
About that last, Larry Arnhart has correctly categorized this maneuver, which Weikart shares with, among other DI stalwarts, John West and his book Darwin Day in America, as follows:
Like Weikart, West [claims] that I am criticizing a straw man because "not everything in the book is directly tied back to Darwin." As West indicates, he does say in his Introduction (p. xvii) that Darwinism is "only one part" of the larger story of "materialistic reductionism" from Democritus to the present. But on that same page, West claims that "the work of Charles Darwin ultimately supplied the empirical basis for a robust materialism finally to take hold."
Like Weikart, West employs a rhetoric of bait and switch. He draws attention to the supposed primacy of Darwin as a source of evil policies, but then when readers ask for evidence and arguments to support this strong claim, he insists that he has never made such a claim.
In short, the Undiscovery Institute drones tell one crude story to the faithful and, when they want to maintain a rag of intellectual integrity to cover themselves, they retreat to caveats about how it is their audience who should go out "on their own" to find out what they aren't being told by the very people who claimed the connection in the first place.
But beyond the disingenuousness, let's look at the central claim: that the supposed "replacement" of "Judeo-Christian sanctity-of-life ethics" with "evolutionary ethics," somehow, in some unspecified manner, "influenced" Hitler and the Nazis. Ignoring those "Gott Mit Uns" belt buckles the Nazis wore or Hitler's proclamations of doing "the Lord's work;" forgetting the "influence" of Luther and a thousand years of Christian anti-Semitism on Hitler; overlooking Darwin's own invocation of "the noblest part of our nature" against simplistic attempts to apply selection within human societies; and paying no mind to the fact that, well before Hitler had embarked on his murderous spree, evolutionary science had shown that eugenics could never work; does Weikart's claim even make sense on its own terms?
The claim that it was "evolutionary ethics" (whatever that might be) replacing Christian ethics that freed Hitler to pursue crimes against humanity only holds water if Christian ethics would have prevented or massively ameliorated the Nazi program. What evidence is there of that? Slavery, in which millions died and were horribly abused, prospered under Christianity and was defended with vigor from the pulpit. The Crusades, the Thirty Years War, the Inquisition and numerous other examples show the compatibility of "Judeo-Christian ethics" with the condemnation of "the other" and exercising the "final solution" of putting them to fire and the sword.
Weikart has attempted to excuse Hitler's explicit invocation of Christian ethics by claiming that the Nazis' "Christianity was always interpreted through the lens of their racial ideology, not vice versa." But, as Larry Arnhart points out, exactly the same can be said of what the eugenicists and Nazis did with evolutionary theory, including the mistake that Weikart himself promotes. In his next book, Weikart will claim that "Hitler's ideology revolved around evolutionary ethics ... whatever promoted evolutionary progress is good and whatever hinders it is bad." Since evolution doesn't promise progress, especially not within the human species, Weikart is merely positing that Hitler misunderstood evolution as badly as he did Christianity.
Weikart is either as ignorant of evolutionary theory as Hitler was or, like Hitler, he has no compunction about using any misrepresentation, any lie, to advance his own agenda.
_____________________
Professor Arnhart is a good source of criticism of Weikart and his book, as is Pat Hayes' unfortunately inactive blog, Red State Rabble.
.
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2008/03/a_question_for_ben_stein_why_are_you_sin.php
There seems to have been more affinity with Koch and Pasteur, and I would add Mendel, than there was to Darwin. Add to that that there is some evidence of an opposition to Darwin: the idea that Aryans could be related to gorillas wasn't apt to go over very well; and they surely didn't think that natural selection could be trusted.
Tom S.
mont blanc pens
oakley sunglasses
ray ban sunglasses
longchamp handbags
fitflops clearance
coach factory outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors handbags
ralph lauren
kate spade outlet
abercrombie
abercrombie outlet
true religion jeans
cheap jordans
cheap jerseys
mont blanc
michael kors handbags
insanity workout dvd
celine outlet
christian louboutin outlet
gucci outlet
ed hardy outlet
lebron james basketball shoes
coach factorty outlet
hollister co
retro jordans
true religion jeans
louis vuitton outlet
coach factory outlet
toms shoes
marc jacobs
air max uk
hollister
burberry outlet
christian louboutin outlet
oakley sunglasses
true religion outlet
oakley sunglasses
kate spade handbags
prada outlet
tory burch outlet
coach outlet store online
oakley sunglasses discount
ralph lauren uk
pandora outlet
michael kors uk
nike blazer
soccer shoes
hollister clothing
gucci outlet
longchamp outlet
abercrombie
coach outlet online
hollister clothing store
ray ban glasses
burberry handbags
nike tn pas cher
mont blanc pen
michael kors outlet
cheap beats
fitflops sale clearance
michael kors handbags
gucci outlet
tory burch shoes
ed hardy
michael kors outlet online
abercrombie outlet
coach outlet
kate spade handbags
cheap ray ban sunglasses
michael kors
pandora charms 2015
kate spade bags
oakley sunglasses outlet
ray ban wayfarer
ray ban uk
lebron 12
nike air huarache
ugg sale
uggs for chea
polo ralph lauren
adidas originals store
kevin durant shoes
pandora charms
oakley sunglasses
ugg boots clearance
north face jackets
coach outlet online
louis vuitton outlet stores
coach outlet
michael kors outlet
louis vuitton bags
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet clearance
canada goose coats
ugg sale
ugg boots sale
cheap uggs sale
michael kors handbags
lebron james basketball shoes
jordan concords
uggs on sale
michael kors handbags
canada goose outlet
louis vuitton purses
ray-ban sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
abercrombie & fitch
louis vuitton outlet stores
jordan shoes
michaek kors outlet
oakley outlet
toms outlet
uggs outlet
coach factory outlet online
vans sneakers
nfl flags wholesaleHouston Oilers stars and stripes flags
Miami Dolphins banners, House Divided Flags,Sports Flags 3x5, Sports flags and banners,nfl House Divided Flags
maglia calcio poco prezzo Maglia real madrid 2017
maglia AC milan online
ray ban sunglasses
oakley sunglasses
true religion jeans
ray bans
omega watches for sale
yeezy boost 350 black
converse shoes
michael kors handbags
dolce and gabbana shoes
20170407
true religion outlet
coach outlet
gucci borse
pandora charms
nike store
los angeles lakers jerseys
kate spade
oklahoma city thunder
ugg outlet
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالباحة
شركة جلي بلاط بالباحة
شركة تسليك مجاري بالباحة
شركة كشف تسربات المياة بالباحة
oakley sunglasses wholesale
detroit lions jerseys
reebok shoes
christian louboutin shoes
canada goose
bottega veneta
polo ralph lauren
jimmy choo shoes
redskins jerseys
Cara Menghilangkan Bruntusan
Obat Penyakit Susah Kencing
Cara Mengobati Gondok Beracun
Cara Mengobati Gabagen
Cara Mudah Mengobati Diabetes
Cara Menyembuhkan Mata Minus
fitflops sale clearance
ferragamo shoes
oakley sunglasses
michael kors outlet
canada goose outlet
uggs outlet
oakley sunglasses
isabel marant shoes
ralph lauren outlet
cheap jordans
true religion jeans
ugg boots on sale 70% off
issey miyake
jordan shoes
canada goose outlet
christian louboutin shoes
adidas outlet online
yeezy shoes
ugg boots clearance
ralph lauren outlet
louboutin shoes
lebron 16
westbrook shoes
off white jordan 1
adidas tubular
hogan outlet online
longchamp outlet
nike air max 2017
michael kors handbags
ralph lauren polo
red bottom shoes
true religion
skechers shoes
fitflops clearance
north face
supreme clothing
yeezy boots 350
adidas yeezy
bape clothing
canada goose outlet
kawhi leonard shoes
jordan 6
kd 12
longchamp bags
jordan shoes
yeezy boost 350
golden goose sneakers
supreme hoodie
kyrie 5 spongebob
off white clothing
curry 8
golden goose outlet
moncler
supreme clothing
bape
kyrie shoes
<< Home