Thursday, November 08, 2007
Tempest, Meet Teacup
I think the whole Anthony Flew hullabaloo is now officially out of hand.
John Lynch at Stranger Fruit has written about an entry Flew authored on eugenics for Prometheus Books' New Encyclopedia of Unbelief. I've admired for some time John's deep knowledge of the history and philosophy of science and his sober opinions on the blog wars over attitudes of "intolerance" versus "appeasement" at the interface of religion and science.
John's account of the article certainly raises doubts about Flew's views ... not to mention the editor's judgment (unfortunately, since John is also a contributor). But, without more, I'd have to say that it is premature, at least, to throw around terms like "eugenic leanings" in connection with Flew. Now it has been picked up by PZ Myers as "Antony Flew was, and maybe is, a eugenics sympathizer." Supposedly, "This is really going to mess up the great story of his conversion." Naturally, this version of events will now be aired far and wide.
I guess it would be useless to point out that, according to the information given by John, it is likely that Flew wrote the entry on eugenics after his "conversion." Thus, trying to have it both ways ... he converted because he is in mental decline but the eugenics article can be mined for an accurate, rather than confused, account of his beliefs ... might be a tad unjustified.
This near obsession both sides have for one old man and his beliefs is, to say the least, unseemly in the extreme.
.
Comments:
<< Home
I'm just waiting for someone in the atheist camp to say 'See, he believes in God now and is losing his ability to reason the way he used to! Coincidence?'
Christians are notorious for placing anyone who has a conversion of any sort and is a public figure in the spotlight immediately - often with unfortunate results.
Thanks for providing a reasonable attempt to bring calm!
Christians are notorious for placing anyone who has a conversion of any sort and is a public figure in the spotlight immediately - often with unfortunate results.
Thanks for providing a reasonable attempt to bring calm!
I'm just waiting for someone in the atheist camp to say 'See, he believes in God now and is losing his ability to reason the way he used to! Coincidence?'
Have you checked the comments at PZ's blog lately? I'd be surprised if someone hasn't already said something much the same. Of course, that doesn't answer why an Encyclopedia of Unbelief would go ahead and publish it ... can't unbelievers reason well?
And so it goes ...
Thanks for providing a reasonable attempt to bring calm!
For some reason I've always had this penchant for pissing into the wind.
Have you checked the comments at PZ's blog lately? I'd be surprised if someone hasn't already said something much the same. Of course, that doesn't answer why an Encyclopedia of Unbelief would go ahead and publish it ... can't unbelievers reason well?
And so it goes ...
Thanks for providing a reasonable attempt to bring calm!
For some reason I've always had this penchant for pissing into the wind.
> he converted because he is in mental decline
I'd like to point out that I've never claimed this, and I don't really care whether he's declining or not. I don't even really care that he converted.
I do, however, care that he takes a strange view of the history of eugenics and he disses a noted historian while doing so.
I also care to see how the DI - who make a career of decrying Darwin for links to eugenics etc - manage to reconcile their vision of Flew with his writings on this topic.
I'd like to point out that I've never claimed this, and I don't really care whether he's declining or not. I don't even really care that he converted.
I do, however, care that he takes a strange view of the history of eugenics and he disses a noted historian while doing so.
I also care to see how the DI - who make a career of decrying Darwin for links to eugenics etc - manage to reconcile their vision of Flew with his writings on this topic.
I don't really care whether he's declining or not. I don't even really care that he converted.
John, if that's you, I don't mean to lay any of this at your feet (although you had to know it was pouring gas on an already raging fire). There might have been ways to address your concerns about the historical aspects of Flew's article and even the DI's laying of blame for eugenics on "Darwinists" without giving quite such good fodder to less careful combatants, but that's not my concern here. My point is that this is all part and parcel of a community contest between theists and atheists that has nothing to do with the real issues between them.
I also care to see how the DI - who make a career of decrying Darwin for links to eugenics etc - manage to reconcile their vision of Flew with his writings on this topic.
Do you really? Is there likely to be any surprise? They'll equivocate, misrepresent and, when in doubt, lie outright. They'll say 'that's what a lifetime of atheism will do to a person even after he has taken the first tentative steps toward the Truth™.' Maybe they'll throw in a shot about just how dogmatic atheists are -- that they'll even eat one of their own, if if he does nothing more than adopt a pale bit of deism. This kind of spin ain't hard to do, you know. After all, look at the people the DI has doing it for them.
John, if that's you, I don't mean to lay any of this at your feet (although you had to know it was pouring gas on an already raging fire). There might have been ways to address your concerns about the historical aspects of Flew's article and even the DI's laying of blame for eugenics on "Darwinists" without giving quite such good fodder to less careful combatants, but that's not my concern here. My point is that this is all part and parcel of a community contest between theists and atheists that has nothing to do with the real issues between them.
I also care to see how the DI - who make a career of decrying Darwin for links to eugenics etc - manage to reconcile their vision of Flew with his writings on this topic.
Do you really? Is there likely to be any surprise? They'll equivocate, misrepresent and, when in doubt, lie outright. They'll say 'that's what a lifetime of atheism will do to a person even after he has taken the first tentative steps toward the Truth™.' Maybe they'll throw in a shot about just how dogmatic atheists are -- that they'll even eat one of their own, if if he does nothing more than adopt a pale bit of deism. This kind of spin ain't hard to do, you know. After all, look at the people the DI has doing it for them.
huangqihang0520fitflops sale clearance
coach outlet online
michael kors uk
chanel outlet
abercrombie
michael kors handbags
coach outlet store online
kate spade outlet
true religion jeans
gucci uk
ralph lauren uk
tory burch outlet online
chanel bags
air max 95
caoch outlet
christian louboutin sale
oakley sunglasses wholesale
pandora jewelry
michael kors bags
oakley sunglasses
toms shoes
ray ban outlet
cheap jordans
pandora charms
cheap ray ban sunglasses
ray ban sunglasses
gucci outlet
coach factory outlet
q
coach outlet online
michael kors uk
chanel outlet
abercrombie
michael kors handbags
coach outlet store online
kate spade outlet
true religion jeans
gucci uk
ralph lauren uk
tory burch outlet online
chanel bags
air max 95
caoch outlet
christian louboutin sale
oakley sunglasses wholesale
pandora jewelry
michael kors bags
oakley sunglasses
toms shoes
ray ban outlet
cheap jordans
pandora charms
cheap ray ban sunglasses
ray ban sunglasses
gucci outlet
coach factory outlet
q
2015-12-15keyun
lebron 12
nike air huarache
ugg sale
uggs for chea
polo ralph lauren
adidas originals store
kevin durant shoes
pandora charms
oakley sunglasses
ugg boots clearance
north face jackets
coach outlet online
louis vuitton outlet stores
coach outlet
michael kors outlet
louis vuitton bags
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet clearance
canada goose coats
ugg sale
ugg boots sale
cheap uggs sale
michael kors handbags
lebron james basketball shoes
jordan concords
uggs on sale
michael kors handbags
canada goose outlet
louis vuitton purses
ray-ban sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
abercrombie & fitch
louis vuitton outlet stores
jordan shoes
michaek kors outlet
oakley outlet
toms outlet
uggs outlet
coach factory outlet online
vans sneakers
lebron 12
nike air huarache
ugg sale
uggs for chea
polo ralph lauren
adidas originals store
kevin durant shoes
pandora charms
oakley sunglasses
ugg boots clearance
north face jackets
coach outlet online
louis vuitton outlet stores
coach outlet
michael kors outlet
louis vuitton bags
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet clearance
canada goose coats
ugg sale
ugg boots sale
cheap uggs sale
michael kors handbags
lebron james basketball shoes
jordan concords
uggs on sale
michael kors handbags
canada goose outlet
louis vuitton purses
ray-ban sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
abercrombie & fitch
louis vuitton outlet stores
jordan shoes
michaek kors outlet
oakley outlet
toms outlet
uggs outlet
coach factory outlet online
vans sneakers
coach outlet
ed hardy uk
michael kors outlet
prada shoes outlet
basketball shoes
seattle seahawks jerseys
new york giants jerseys
nike store uk
miami heat
michael kors uk
ed hardy uk
michael kors outlet
prada shoes outlet
basketball shoes
seattle seahawks jerseys
new york giants jerseys
nike store uk
miami heat
michael kors uk
www0704
christian louboutin outlet
ugg boots
air max 2017
coach outlet
true religion jeans
bucks jerseys
hermes birkin
simulation shoes
michael kors outlet
cheap football shirts
christian louboutin outlet
ugg boots
air max 2017
coach outlet
true religion jeans
bucks jerseys
hermes birkin
simulation shoes
michael kors outlet
cheap football shirts
www0829
christian louboutin shoes
ralph lauren uk
ugg boots
pandora jewelry
coach outlet online
cheap nba jerseys
jordan shoes
pandora jewelry
nike presto
jordan 8
christian louboutin shoes
ralph lauren uk
ugg boots
pandora jewelry
coach outlet online
cheap nba jerseys
jordan shoes
pandora jewelry
nike presto
jordan 8
www1126
mbt shoes
tod's outlet
pandora jewelry
clarks outlet
kate spade outlet
christian louboutin shoes
michael kors outlet
ralph lauren polo
superdry uk
canada goose jackets
mbt shoes
tod's outlet
pandora jewelry
clarks outlet
kate spade outlet
christian louboutin shoes
michael kors outlet
ralph lauren polo
superdry uk
canada goose jackets
https://www.raybans-outlet.us.com/ Ray Ban Outlet
https://www.raybans-outlet.us.com/ Ray Bans Outlet
https://www.raybans-outlet.us.com/ Ray Bans
https://www.rolexswatches.us.com/ Rolex Watches
https://www.adidasyeezyonlinestore.us/ Adidas Yeezy
https://www.adidasyeezy-shoes.com/ Adidas Yeezy
https://www.adidasyeezy-shoes.com/ Yeezy Shoes
https://www.newyeezys.us/ New Yeezys
https://www.raybans.uk.com/ Ray Bans
https://www.raybans.uk.com/ Ray Bans UK
https://www.raybansglasses.com/ Ray Ban Glasses
https://www.raybansglasses.com/ Ray Ban Sunglasses
https://www.ray-banoutlets.com/ Ray Ban Outlet
https://www.ray-banoutlets.com/ Ray Bans Outlet
https://www.nike-factorys.us.com/ Nike Outlet
https://www.raybans-sunglasses.us/ Ray-Ban Sunglasses
https://www.nike-factorys.us.com/ Nike Factory
https://www.newyeezys.us/ Yeezys
https://www.raybans-sunglasses.us/ Ray Ban Sunglasses
https://www.nikeonlienoutlet.com/ Nike Outlet Online
https://www.nikeonlienoutlet.com/ Nike Outlet
https://www.yeezysshoes.com/ Yeezy Shoes
https://www.niketrainers.uk.com/ Nike Trainers
https://www.niketrainers.uk.com/ Nike UK
https://www.yeezysshoes.com/ Yeezy
https://www.rolexs.us.com/ Rolex
https://www.rolexwatches.uk.com/ Rolex Watches
https://www.pandorajewelrys.us/ Pandora Jewelry
https://www.pandoracharmss.us/ Pandora Charms
https://www.pandorajewelryusa.us.com/ Pandora Jewelry
https://www.charms-pandora.com/ Pandora Charms
https://www.travisscott-jordan1.com/ Travis Scott Jordan 1
https://www.airsjordans.com/ Air Jordans
https://www.jordan-11s.com/ Jordan 11
https://www.jordans-11.com/ Jordan 11
https://www.jordansshoes.org/ Jordans Shoes
https://www.moncler-outlets.com/ Moncler Outlet
https://www.off-white.us.org/ Off White
https://www.yeezy-450.com/ Yeezy 450
https://www.yeezys500.com/ Yeezy 500
https://www.nikeoutlet-factory.com/ Nike Outlet
Post a Comment
https://www.raybans-outlet.us.com/ Ray Bans Outlet
https://www.raybans-outlet.us.com/ Ray Bans
https://www.rolexswatches.us.com/ Rolex Watches
https://www.adidasyeezyonlinestore.us/ Adidas Yeezy
https://www.adidasyeezy-shoes.com/ Adidas Yeezy
https://www.adidasyeezy-shoes.com/ Yeezy Shoes
https://www.newyeezys.us/ New Yeezys
https://www.raybans.uk.com/ Ray Bans
https://www.raybans.uk.com/ Ray Bans UK
https://www.raybansglasses.com/ Ray Ban Glasses
https://www.raybansglasses.com/ Ray Ban Sunglasses
https://www.ray-banoutlets.com/ Ray Ban Outlet
https://www.ray-banoutlets.com/ Ray Bans Outlet
https://www.nike-factorys.us.com/ Nike Outlet
https://www.raybans-sunglasses.us/ Ray-Ban Sunglasses
https://www.nike-factorys.us.com/ Nike Factory
https://www.newyeezys.us/ Yeezys
https://www.raybans-sunglasses.us/ Ray Ban Sunglasses
https://www.nikeonlienoutlet.com/ Nike Outlet Online
https://www.nikeonlienoutlet.com/ Nike Outlet
https://www.yeezysshoes.com/ Yeezy Shoes
https://www.niketrainers.uk.com/ Nike Trainers
https://www.niketrainers.uk.com/ Nike UK
https://www.yeezysshoes.com/ Yeezy
https://www.rolexs.us.com/ Rolex
https://www.rolexwatches.uk.com/ Rolex Watches
https://www.pandorajewelrys.us/ Pandora Jewelry
https://www.pandoracharmss.us/ Pandora Charms
https://www.pandorajewelryusa.us.com/ Pandora Jewelry
https://www.charms-pandora.com/ Pandora Charms
https://www.travisscott-jordan1.com/ Travis Scott Jordan 1
https://www.airsjordans.com/ Air Jordans
https://www.jordan-11s.com/ Jordan 11
https://www.jordans-11.com/ Jordan 11
https://www.jordansshoes.org/ Jordans Shoes
https://www.moncler-outlets.com/ Moncler Outlet
https://www.off-white.us.org/ Off White
https://www.yeezy-450.com/ Yeezy 450
https://www.yeezys500.com/ Yeezy 500
https://www.nikeoutlet-factory.com/ Nike Outlet
<< Home