Thoughts in a Haystack

I'm reading Richard Hofstadter's Anti-intellectualism in America and it is striking how little has changed in the last 45 years. One thing that seems fresh on Hofstadter's page is the way anti-intellectuals go about the business of marginalizing the life of the mind:

It occurs to me that we may have been underestimating our opponents, at least when it comes to low cunning. Texas, in the midst of the ongoing creationist assault on the teaching of evolution, is only the latest place we have been repeatedly hearing the old canard that 'evolution is only a theory.' Frequently the trope is heard in the same company as charges of "elitism" made against scientists and educators.

Most of the time the reaction by the reality-based community is that the notion is merely a misunderstanding of what "theory" means in science or, at worst, a deliberate attempt to confuse evolution with the "man-in-the-street" meaning of the word as a wild-assed guess. But Hofstadter may be right here. "Theory," particularly one identified mostly with academia, could evoke more to the average American than merely an image of barroom speculation. Instead, it might conjure up images of devious drones who might even be enemies of the Republic peddling antidemocratic notions to the youth of America.

I have no magic bullet to counter this ploy, if that is what it is, but it might be well if all and sundry on science's side take every opportunity to emphasize not only the practical worth of evolution as a science but the value of a knowledge of it as an employment qualification for future job-seekers.
.