Thursday, June 11, 2009
Caught In the Middle
Two highly polarized camps agree on one thing: anyone who is trying to steer anything like a middle course and pragmatically achieve the socially possible, while attempting to move the debate in a progressive direction, is to be scorned.
No, I'm not talking about the reaction of both IDers and "incompatiblists" towards theistic evolutionists. This time it's the reaction of fundamentalists and some portions of the LGBT community to President Obama's quiet proclamation of LGBT Pride Month. As described by Nick Street:
One of the ironies in the broader reaction to Obama's maneuvering around the issue of legal parity for queerfolk in various domains of American life is the fact that, like the busybodies on the religious right, many of my gay and lesbian brothers and sisters have a hard time letting themselves feel good about this president.
"Homosexuality is nothing to be proud of," Peter LaBarbera told One News Now, the online news division of the American Family Association. "The fact is people have left the lifestyle," said LaBarbera, president of Americans for Truth About Homosexuality. "People have overcome homosexuality—I think that's something to be proud of." ...
"Obama is a better friend to Rick Warren's constituency than to LGBT," one "homosexual activist" remarked, apropos of the White House press release, on the Advocate's Web site. "In fact, Obama is not now and has never been a friend of LGBT. I didn't believe his lies before November 4, 2008, and I don't believe his lies now."
It isn't the only arena where the concept applies.
.
Why is that?
Quite right ... if we're speaking in absolutist terms about the underlying claims. I think the odds of their being right about how to go about making society as a whole more progressive and pragmatic (assuming one is interested in that result) is rather better than that of either extreme (especially where one of the extremes is definitely not interested in a more progressive and pragmatic society).
Obviously these things can't be judged universally, much less in the abstract, but at least in the gay rights case I think the less pliable hardline types have a stronger track record, dragging society to their view instead of kowtowing to it.
When they go after Obama for not living up to his promises, I think that strategy is on to something. Hard to argue with track-record. Not much point being an uncritical support base in any case...
I think it's a combination, actually, where the militants stir the social pot and the moderates pave the way to greater acceptance. Still, I don't see the necessity to attack the moderates -- at least vociferously. It's a fine line between being a gadfly and being a smudge on a flyswatter.
"Still, I don't see the necessity to attack the moderates -- at least vociferously"
The analogy having served its purpose, if we revert to the original religious question, I think Chad Orzel at Scienceblogs had it right. I think the best way to account for the hostility between the Dawkinsians and theistic evolutionists is simply to note that the former have additional goals the former don't share - they want to weaken the role of religion in society for many reasons having nothing to do with evolution and ID. It's clearly not the case that in this respect a Ken Miller can meet them halfway.
Moderate and extreme gay rights activists have roughly similar goals and goals, by contrast.
I really value your blog site on Blogger: Thoughts in a Haystack & will be back again.
Thank you...
Feel free to visit my web blog :: Gas Mileage
I'm wondering if you may be interested in doing a website link exchange? I see your blog: http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=14771541&postID=8022568274070937914 and my website are based mostly around the same subject matter. I'd
love to switch links or possibly guest author a article for you.
Thanks for your time.
Also visit my web blog: Shooting Games
coach outlet online
michael kors uk
chanel outlet
abercrombie
michael kors handbags
coach outlet store online
kate spade outlet
true religion jeans
gucci uk
ralph lauren uk
tory burch outlet online
chanel bags
air max 95
caoch outlet
christian louboutin sale
oakley sunglasses wholesale
pandora jewelry
michael kors bags
oakley sunglasses
toms shoes
ray ban outlet
cheap jordans
pandora charms
cheap ray ban sunglasses
ray ban sunglasses
gucci outlet
coach factory outlet
q
abercrombie and fitch kids
gucci sale
true religion jeans
ugg outlet
michael kors handbags
hugo boss outlet
bills jerseys
jacksonville jaguars jersey
mont blanc pens outlet
cheap jordans
nmd
nhl jerseys
nike mercurial vapor
true religion outlet
calvin klein outlet
yeezy
adidas tubular UK
adidas stan smith
nike mercurial
tom ford sunglasses
pandora charms
fitflops
true religion outlet
van cleef arpels
nike sneakers
jordan shoes
nike basketball shoes
kobe shoes
christian louboutin shoes
vapormax
fitflops
adidas superstar
adidas nmd
lebron soldier 11
michael kors
yeezy boost 350 v2
givenchy jewelry
nike air max 2015
bape clothing
coach outlet
ferragamo outlet
air jordan 12
pandora charms
bulgari jewelry
true religion jeans
polo ralph lauren
true religion jeans
ugg boots on sale 70% off
issey miyake
jordan shoes
canada goose outlet
christian louboutin shoes
adidas outlet online
yeezy shoes
ugg boots clearance
ralph lauren outlet
yeezy boost 350 v2
yeezy boost 380
off white x jordan 1
golden goose sneakers
jordan shoes
curry 6
yeezy boost 350 v2
moncler
yeezy boost 350
<< Home