Monday, August 09, 2010
[T]he "responsible" argument against the Islamic center ... goes something like this:
Those who are opposing the mosque as part of an effort to conflate all Islam with the 9/11 attacks are bigoted and wrong. But there are vague associations between Islam and the attacks -- Osama said he carried the attacks out in Islam's name, and the attackers were Islamic -- and this is hurtful to 9/11 families. Proceeding with the center will only undermine efforts to achieve the reconciliation the center is designed to achieve. Therefore, all legal niceties aside, it must be opposed.
Here's the problem with this argument: It doesn't reckon with the question of whether it's legitimate to see the construction of an Islamic center near Ground Zero as an inherently provocative act. Either it's legit to see the building of the center as provocative, or it isn't.
The only way to see this as a provocative act is to buy into the notion that the building of a center devoted to Islamic heritage is, by accident or by design, tantamount to rubbing the victims' noses into what happened on 9/11 -- that it is inescapably a "victory mosque." To believe this is to legitimize -- wittingly or not -- the world view of the center's bigoted foes.
In fact, it is not legitimate to see the building of a center devoted to the study of Islam near Ground Zero as an inherently provocative act. You can't endorse the idea that it's provocative to study the heritage of Islam in the vicinity of Ground Zero while simultaneously arguing that the bigots are wrong to conflate the 9/11 attacks with Islam as a whole. Period. It's not a coherent or sustainable argument.
- Greg Sargent, "The "responsible" argument against the Ground Zero mosque," The Plum Line
They agree with the Islamists on most of what they want to restrict and destroy, just differing on a few details.
I require an expert in this space to solve my problem.
May be that is you! Having a look forward to peer you.
my web-site: Louis Vuitton Bags
to find out about this topic. You understand so much its almost hard to argue with you (not that I personally would want to…HaHa).
You certainly put a brand new spin on a topic that's been discussed for many years. Excellent stuff, just excellent!
Feel free to surf to my homepage - Cheap NFL Jerseys