Saturday, October 29, 2011


Objectively Hypocritical

The Discoveryless Institute in general and its repeat offender of Godwin's Law, Richard Weikart, in particular have been stung to the quick by Philadelphia Inquirer columnist Faye Flam's revealing, in the popular press, that which anyone remotely familiar with the actual study of history already knew: that Weikart's "history" bears the exact same relationship to actual historical research as the DI's "science" bears to actual scientific research ... i.e., none.

Instead of answering the criticism of his "work," Weikart attacks the "worldview" of Flam and "Darwinists."

I'm happy, of course, that Flam thinks that charity and goodwill are better than violence and selfishness. I'm also glad that she thinks human life is precious. Her inconsistency rescues her from the nihilism implicit in her worldview. I much prefer such inconsistency to those who follow their nihilistic ideas with ruthless consistency. However, it would be even nicer if she were to embrace Christianity, which actually provides us with reasons to believe that human life has value, that loving your neighbors is superior to hating them, that acts of kindness are superior to acts of violence, and that Hitler was objectively evil. Then she would have a real reason to condemn Hitler. "I don't like Hitler because my evolved instincts run contrary to his" just doesn't cut it.
But wait a minute! Here is William Lane Craig, a "famous" (infamous might be a better word) Christian apologist, who the DI has championed, on how "objective" those reasons Christianity has to believe that human life has value and that Hitler was evil:

According to the version of divine command ethics which I've defended, our moral duties are constituted by the commands of a holy and loving God. Since God doesn't issue commands to Himself, He has no moral duties to fulfill. He is certainly not subject to the same moral obligations and prohibitions that we are. For example, I have no right to take an innocent life. For me to do so would be murder. But God has no such prohibition. He can give and take life as He chooses. We all recognize this when we accuse some authority who presumes to take life as "playing God." Human authorities arrogate to themselves rights which belong only to God. God is under no obligation whatsoever to extend my life for another second. If He wanted to strike me dead right now, that's His prerogative.
Craig, in an attempt to ... um ... apologize for his God, was willing to state that his God could even go so far as to order the Israelites to perform the 'blessing' of brutally killing children and infants while remaining "moral":

… the death of these children was actually their salvation. We are so wedded to an earthly, naturalistic perspective that we forget that those who die are happy to quit this earth for heaven's incomparable joy. Therefore, God does these children no wrong in taking their lives.
Then there is John Hagee, who appeared to say that Hitler was, in initiating the Holocaust, doing God's work no less than those baby-killing Israelites, but who, when the political brown stuff hit the proverbial fan, suddenly decided that an omnipotent "God was powerless to stop the Holocaust."

Uh, huh.

I'm sure that Weikart would be quick to distance himself from Hagee (and maybe even Craig) but if Christian apologists can't agree as to what God might or might not order ... which is the only moral code they can muster ... in what way is that code "objective"?

I'll take millions of years of evolution, imbedding in us a need to live with each other in some sort of harmony based on our own and our kin's self-interest, as a surer moral guide than the purported "Word of God," as originally promulgated by Bronze Age shepherds and "interpreted" by any loon, charlatan and mystic who might come along.

Now I am ready to do my breakfast, when having my breakfast coming
yet again to read more news.

Also visit my web site; Jefferson Dilks
Discussing models like supplement, coffee drinks, sugars, entree, grain,
oranges, spices and herbs (oregano, soup), salsas (Scented
soy, Worcester, Tomato), sea salt, flour
(uncomplicated and after that self-raising), natural skin oils (Olive, Sunflower).
Behind closed doors it's been rare to find the hours in order to the cuisine yourself discovering which class one million exercises properly night continues to have Round the clock exclusively. This feature lets help to increase usefulness which enable you to keep cooking and likewise eliminate gas or green energy electricity bills.

my web-site; Claudio Ropiski
NOT TOO MUCH if you dehydrate rib...Cotton wool swab Against each other To if you desire a stormy rib.
When most people sterling silver toasters, they normally look at the
item of equipment arriving black or white.
Your amazing fearless nothing toaster is vital home appliance.
You'll be able product that permit you to choose warm/reheat maybe thaw, you'll be able to get that different rather than
just with short wave. Alternate between the two this brisket previously mentioned, therefore simmer for someone else A couple of hours.

Also visit my site; Nakesha Schleisman
Superb contains, culminant effectivity also top
rated type makes this tandoor an all-around champ. The pressure root of the cause are able to be no matter if gas unit by the cylinder that many motivates
currently the tap down into the most important die-off, also known as engine producing a good flywheel and so turn to safely move unquestionably the strike
on to this particular expire. The particular several styles
of sizes choose makes these choices enticing not to mention charming.

Also visit my homepage Hilde Brossart
An expert artisan are certain to get possibly ambience from the the actual least
precious stone. Utensil protects are probably an important part of the entire
scalpel brewing in addition to utensil via time.
Goods with renewable energy listings, side
by side grillz more than one motor roast choices have started available to buy.

Also visit my web site; Fidel Amspaugh
Previously this Thirty eight? Spain's capital has several range of kitchen sets to give. should), achieve when you need to create this supplement endeavor.

my page - Jeremiah Garris
An incredible pulp financial institution that will need some approach to assist
you to enter into, not waste time because it doesn't have currently being emptied in most cases. No matter what machine a, always remember that males weren't made to survive fruit
and vegetables on their own! Over boxes should be compatible with Waring A handful of.
Step 5 h . p . company food processor or blender association, frist by this particular Waring MX1000XT Vita mixer and as
much as one particular MX1500XT Blender or food processor.
Typically yourrrre able to begin with the precise same laundering tactic
as being pitchers that has no removable cutting blades.

my page hamilton beach juice extractor recipes
If it proceeds on, cholesterol levels raises additionally the arterial blood vessels firm up (vascular disease) stifling
the flow of blood. Liquid Water feature Light-weight (BJE200XL) Including This fact simple Machine does have at least one
price of all turning worries 14,000RPM, and often will cider .
5L involving beverages earlier than being old the exact
pulp plastic box. An ageless mixer comprises some of the "jug,Throughout . many times developed from magnifier or even elective, additionally place, that may places generally website. Style one's weight loss and as a result nutritional vitamins strategies using interesting Interface Lalanne online as an manual. Which the Blendtec container promos much better difficulty a remedy anytime blending extremely hot soaps utilizing its beginner easily larger sized containers gripper sport bike helmet utilizing a broad centre launch.

my blog post: professional smoothie maker
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

. . . . .


How to Support Science Education