Saturday, May 02, 2015

 

Meme Mayhem!


This an expansion on a comment I left over at Ed Brayton's blog. It seems there is a new meme going around the bigotsphere to the effect that, during the oral arguments on Obergefell v. Hodges, Solicitor General Donald B. Verrilli, Jr., on behalf of President Obama, has “declared war” on the religious rights of clergy and churches.

Here is Conservative commentator Robert Knight, speaking on Huntington-based talk radio host Tom Roten's program:
And here is one final thing, Tom, that was scary: that was Don Verrilli, the Solicitor General arguing on behalf of President Obama for gay marriage, and he was asked by one of the Justices 'what about the possibility that pastors will be forced ...forced … against their beliefs to perform same-sex ceremonies and he just casually said 'well, that'll probably be left up to the states, although it is already an issue in states that have gay marriage.' Now think, in the free country of ours, they're casually talking about using the power of the state to force pastors to bless something that the Bible says is an abomination.
And here is Glenn Beck:
“Hear’s (sic) my prediction: If gay marriage goes through the Supreme Court and gay marriage becomes fine and they can put teeth in it – so now they can go after the churches, like the president’s lawyer says – 50% of our churches will fall away. Meaning the congregations, within five years, 50% of the congregants will fall away from their church. Because they won’t be able to take the persecution,” Glenn said. “Because the stigma of going to church will be too much.”
This is a meme we're going to be seeing a lot of in the future, I suspect. What Knight said above is simply not true. You can find the transcript of the oral arguments here. The question about clergy being forced to perform same-sex marriages was asked of the main attorney for the appellants, Mary L. Bonauto, by Justice Scalia and Bonauto, with an assist by Justice Ginsberg, answered “No.” Although it wasn't raised in the oral arguments, there is the “ministerial exception” to anti-discrimination laws on hiring and the same logic would apply to anyone who brought a discrimination claim against clergy for not performing a same-sex marriage.

Verrilli was asked by Justice Roberts:
We have a concession from your friend that clergy will not be required to perform same-sex marriage, but there are going to be harder questions. Would a religious school that has married housing be required to afford such housing to same-sex couples?
Verrilli's answer was rather convoluted and not very clear but basically he said 1) the Court would only be answering what the states have to do under the Fourteenth Amendment, not individuals; 2) the issue would depend on the civil rights laws of the states or local governments [which is where the supporters of same-sex bans and the bigots that voted for them want that decision to be made and where, in any event, the “ministerial exception” would still apply]; 3) the Federal government has no anti-discrimination law covering sexual orientation [and, given our present Congress, isn't likely to have any in the foreseeable future]; 4) such questions are going to arise even if states are allowed to ban same-sex marriages [as in the Houston anti-discrimination law flap in Texas, a state that still doesn't allow same-sex marriages].

Asked by Justice Alito:
Well, in the Bob Jones case, the Court held that a college was not entitled to tax-exempt status if it opposed interracial marriage or interracial dating. So would the same apply to a university or a college if it opposed same-sex marriage?
… Verrilli said it could be an issue but would depend on what the particular circumstances were.

The answer to Justice Roberts' question is, assuming there is a state or local law forbidding discrimination in hiring based on sexual orientation and assuming that housing is part of the compensation for the job, does the job involve the “ministry” of the school (which can include duties constituting as little a 45 minutes a day of the person's work)? If it is, then the school is protected. If housing is given to, say, a landscaper or a cook who has no interaction with students, then the school might be in violation of the statute. Of course, many, if not most or all, such anti-discrimination laws specifically exempt religious organizations entirely.

So if you see anyone saying that the Obama administration has “declared war” on churches based on the oral arguments, put them down as low-information morons … like Beck and, apparently, Knight.

Comments:
Re the matter of being forced to solemnize same-sex marriages: Do not churches already have carte blanche to refuse to marry anyone at all, for any reason? Some will only marry members in good standing, others require the couple to attend marriage prep seminars as a condition. Why is this even a question?
 
While Scalia tried to muddy those waters, I think it is quite clear that no church or clergy need to perform SSMs. There was a case a year or two where a church refused to perform an interracial marriage and no one thought it could be brought up on discrimination charges, despite Loving v. Virginia/
 
There seems to be an alarmingly virulent strain of paranoia around the country. I was taken aback to see how people were seeing training exercises for special forces in Texas as being preparations for a military takeover of the country by Obama and that he was planning not to leave office in 2016. I can see how the persecution of Christians line will play well to people who think like that.
 
Ian:

Didn't Jesus say something like 'the crazies will always be with you'?

In point of fact, the virulent paranoia has been with us all along. Bill Buckley, in one of the better things he did, managed to kick them out of mainstream conservatism and contain them in the likes of the John Birch Society.

In 2007, with the prospect of a black president, the crazies came out in sufficient force in so-called tea parties that the economic wing of the Republican Party thought it could harness them. To call it a Faustian bargain is a great understatement and now they are stuck with them.

But there is nothing new about the paranoia, it was just below the surface before but now it's front and center for all to see.
 
الان يمكنك التواصل مع صيانة كاريير وطلب خدمات الصيانة الفورية علي ايدي خبراء وفنيين مدربين عن طريق مهندسيين يمكنك زيارة اقرب فروع توكيل كاريير والتعرف علي عروض شراء الاجهزه الكهربائية المنزلية الحديثة عن طريق طلب رقم صيانة كاريير والتعرف علي المزيد

 


This article is interesting and useful. Thank you for sharing. And let me share an article about health that God willing will be very useful. Thank you :)

Cara Mengobati Sinusitis
Cara Mengatasi asam Lambung
Cara Mengobati Usus Buntu
Khasiat dan manfaat QnC Jelly Gamat
Cara Cepat Mengobati Amandel
Cara Mengobati ruam Kulit pada Bayi

 
0802jejeasics gel lyte iii chaussures Le processus nike huarache pas cher chine de développement de chaussures bon marché pour être vendu au Brésil nike chaussures de running nécessite des contributions internationales qui ne peuvent être new balance chaussures taille réalisées au siège. Ce sérum contient de nombreux baskets asics bleu marine éléments qui aident les problèmes de peau humaine et nike homme les imperfections telles que les protéines, les molécules nike dynamo free print de glyco, les enzymes, les peptides et les oligoéléments. asics gel noosa tri 8 Chaussures

 
0802jejeLes ophtalmologistes, Asics France même ceux qui exercent déjà leur profession, sont mis air jordan femme rose et blanche au courant de recherches récentes et avancées nike air max 1 og pas cher sur la méthode de traitement new balance femme cuir marron des maladies oculaires de leurs clients. Les basket nike presto femme emplois à Stockport sont en demande nike air max 90 noir argent populaire, mais le taux d'emploi est nike air presto fleece khaki toujours supérieur à la moyenne nationale à 75,5%. nike air max thea premium desert camo wmns

 
I love all the things you share and see your beautiful creation. Thank you for sharing with everyone.
แม่และเด็ก

 
شركة عزل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة
العزل من أهم الأعمال التي تقوم بتنفيذها شركتنا، فهي تحافظ على نظافة خزانات المياه وتمنع من تفاعل المياه بأي من المواد الغير طبيعية أو الطبيعية، إضافة إلى أن العزل في حد ذاته من المواد التي تحافظ على خزان المياه وتطيل من عمره وتحافظ على المياه من أن تتعرض للجراثيم والفيروسات.

 
شركات مكافحة حمام بالرياض

يعتبر الحمام من الطيور الأليفة التي لا تسبب الكثير من الأضرار الصحية للأفراد بشكل عام لكن عملية المكافحة الخاصة بها تتم فور دخولها إلى المنازل وبالتالي تسبب الكثير من الإزعاج لساكنى المكان مع إمكانية تكسير عدد من الإكسسوارات بالمنزل مما يمنع أصحاب المكان من فتح النوافذ بشكل مستمر للتهوية لذلك توفر شركة مكافحة الحمام بالرياض مجموعة عوازل مميزة تحد من هذا الأمر

 
Abha Transport Company شركة نقل اثاث بابها
would like to deal with Abha Transport company feel with her reassurance on your furniture and your luggage and ensure that you transport your luggage safely and peacefully,


شركه نقل اثاث بالمدينة المنورة

شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالمدينة المنورة

Introduction of Hafr Al-Batin Cleaning Company: Cleanliness of the faith, and recommended us Almighty cleanliness in ... Hafr Al-Batin Cleaning Company offers service in Hafr Al-Batin and all surrounding areas, .... Transport company transfer Dawadmi شركة تنظيف بحفر الباطن

شركة تسليك مجارى بالمدينة المنورة
شركة تنظيف بحفر الباطن

We come to the best furniture transport company with the lowest prices, which areWant the best furniture move her door Hahi شركة نقل اثاث بابها

شركه نقل اثاث بالمدينة المنورة

شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالمدينة المنورة
Want the best furniture move her door Hahi شركة نقل اثاث بابها

Due to the level of quality provided by our company almaher Company شركة تنظيف بحفر الباطن
cleaning and cleaning services of air conditioning and sewage and insect control on all household services that we doشركة تنظيف بحفر الباطن
and taking our prices suitable for all segments of society, has become the best and most important company in the field of cleaning. شركة تنظيف بحفر الباطن
In order to maintain our success and progress, the company strives to continue along the same lines, through continuous development and the constant pursuit of following all that is best for the masters of customers. شركة تنظيف بحفر الباطن
So, never hesitate our dear customer to contact us if you want daily, weekly or monthly cleaning for your home, your garden or your company, شركة تسليك مجارى بالمدينة المنورة
or even want any kind of cleaning services, we will promptly meet your request with perfect quality and low cost .

 
Jual Obat Aborsi Asli | Obat Cytotec Asli | 082241083319

jual obat aborsi pills cytotec asli manjur untuk menggugurkan kandungan usia 1 - 6 bulan gugur tuntas.CYTOTEC OBAT ASLI sangat efektif mengatasi TELAT DATANG BULANdan menjadikan anda gagal hamil , CYTOTEC adalah OBAT ABORSI 3 JAM BERHASIL GUGUR TUNTAS dengan kwalitas terbaik produk asli pfizer nomor 1 di dunia medis


OBAT ABORSI DI BATAM
OBAT ABORSI DI LOMBOK
OBAT ABORSI DI NTB
OBAT ABORSI DI ACEH
OBAT ABORSI DI RIAU
OBAT ABORSI DI BENGKULU



 
Hire Best Packers And Movers Mumbai for hassle-free Household Shifting, ***Office Relocation, ###Car Transporation, Loading Unloading, packing Unpacking at affordable Price Quotation. Top Rated, Safe and Secure Service Providers who can help you with 24x7 and make sure a Untroubled Relocation Services at Cheapest/Lowest Rate @ Packers And Movers Mumbai

 
Amazing article. Your blog helped me to improve myself in many ways thanks for sharing this kind of wonderful informative blogs in live. I have bookmarked more article from this website. Such a nice blog you are providing ! Kindly Visit Us @ Packers and Movers Kolkata
 

Superb post, we enjoyed each and everything as per written in your post. Thank you for this informative article because it’s really helpful, I really like site.
Please visit our website: @ Packers and Movers Kolkata

 
Packers and Movers Bangalore Home Services Bangalore based Company which offers versatile solutions, Right team that easily reduce the stress associated with a ShiftHousehold Shifting, *** Vehicle Transportation. Affordable, Reliable Shifting Services, Compare Shifting Charges @ Packers And Movers Bangalore

 
I like this article.I was searching over search engines and found your blog and its really helps thank you so much @ Packers and Movers mumbai
 
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

. . . . .

Organizations

Links
How to Support Science Education
archives