Wednesday, March 23, 2011


Their Lips Are Moving ...

It's John West's turn to lie today.

He's kvetching about Lauri Lebo who, according to West:

... rewrites history by suggesting that the focus on the critical analysis of Darwin's theory (rather than the teaching of intelligent design) is somehow a post-Dover development.

There is actually one and a half lies here ... or an inability of West to read, which is always a possibility with creationists. Lebo didn't say that this was a new tactic since the Dover case, she said:

As always, since intelligent design was ruled unconstitutional in Kitzmiller v. Dover, the introduced bills rely on such creationist code words as "teaching the controversy," "academic freedom," or "critical analysis." (Emphasis added)

That's true enough and is a direct result of the DI launching its "Model Academic Freedom Statute on Evolution" in 2008.

More importantly on the lying front, West touts a press release [snort!] about how it gulled the Ohio State Board of Education, first into a benchmark in 2002 and then a model lesson plan in 2004, on the "Critical Analysis of Evolution," which the board later regretted and reversed precisely because the nature of the ID Movement was revealed for all to see in the Kitzmiller decision. The DI press release claims:

[T]he lesson plan is exactly the approach to teaching evolution that Discovery Institute has advocated all along, helping students learn both the scientific strengths and weaknesses of Darwin’s theory. ...

The lesson plan does not discuss religion or alternative scientific theories such as intelligent design.

What West is covering up is that, in 2005, after things had gone badly in the Kitzmiller trial but before the decision was handed down, the DI was saying:

We strongly believe that teaching about intelligent design is constitutionally permissible, but we think mandatory inclusion of intelligent design in public school curricula is ill-advised. Instead, we recommend that schools require only that the scientific evidence for and against neo-Darwinism be taught, while not infringing on the academic freedom of teachers to present appropriate information about intelligent design if they choose.

In other words, phrases like "teaching the controversy," "academic freedom," and "critical analysis" are just intended to be a cover to allow teachers who are creationists or who want to avoid problems with creationist parents by throwing them a sop -- which we know amounts to all too many teachers -- to bring ID into the classroom.

The DI's position is clearly a subterfuge to get ID into public schools by hook or by crook ... which is more than enough reason to stop listening when their lips start to move.


Update: Lauri Lebo has now responded to West. Wes Elsberry also noticed.


I enjoyed over read your blog post. Your blog have nice information, I got good ideas from this amazing blog. I am always searching like this type blog post. I hope I will see again..

0802jejeBeaucoup pensent nike air jordan 11 retro low gs citrus que la ligne de chaussures DC et d'autres avis site nike requin pas cher de ce marché vont faire des air jordan 9 anthracite release date progrès cette année et réduire certaines nike air max 1 essential grise femme des autres ventes sur le marché nike air max thea noir et saumon en 2011. Maintenant, pour ne pas dire asics gel nimbus pour femme qu'il n'y a pas d'excellents produits air jordan homme paris là-bas que nous devons toujours prendre, nike sportswear air max 1 essential pas cher mais une grande majorité de suppléments new balance hommes running course nous nuisent plutôt que de nous aider.

La marche est un moyen sain de chaussure adidas zx flux bleu blanc soulager l'arthrite du pied et du bas du dos. Malgré le fait d'être accompli tout au-dessus de 410 ° C, un parapet était supplémentaire à travers le temple pour empêcher les gens aujourd'hui de glisser du bastion escarpé. Je réalise le dilemme que vous pourriez éventuellement vous poser en ce moment. Non seulement les chaussures mesureront cette information, mais elles vous fourniront aussi le feedback et les résultats via air jordan 19 pas cher votre smartphone! Maintenant c'est tout simplement génial! Il a également annoncé que Lebron James sera le premier joueur à endosser et à endosser les baskets. Profitez du cadeau de la nature pour une belle peau et regardez vos chéloïdes disparaître naturellement et magnifiquement. Quelqu'un a évalué: Décidé d'acquérir plus vital sur le asics gel lyte v blanche bordeaux golf, j'ai acheté cela pour être un démarreur établi pour moi-même.

Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

. . . . .


How to Support Science Education